|
It is extremely difficult to obtain information about the financial cost of detention. Read the Parliamentary question of Dr. Silvana Koch-Mehrin MEP regarding this aspect: http://www.europarl.europa.eu/omk/sipade3?PUBREF=-//EP//TEXT+WQ+E-2005-1297+0+DOC+XML+V0 //EN&L=EN&LEVEL=2&NAV=S&LSTDOC=Y
AUSTRIA
There is no doubt that all forms of open accommodation are cheaper to run than closed centres. However, there may be costs saved by ensuring, by means of detention, that rejected asylum seekers who can be returned home are available for immediate return (if an individual assessment indicates a risk of absconding). SOURCE: UNHCR LEGAL AND PROTECTION POLICY, RESEARCH SERIES, Alternatives to Detention of Asylum Seekers and Refugees, Ophelia Field with the assistance of Alice Edwards, External Consultants, DIVISION OF INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION SERVICES, POLAS/2006/03, April 2006, Extract, page 69
BELGIUM
In 2004, one day of one person in detention centre costs (at least) 38,10 UR This is the amount, which Belgium requires from airlines that transported irregular migrants to Belgium whom they were not supposed to transport and who were consequently detained in Belgium:
Frais de séjour En application avec l'article 74/4 de la loi du 15/12/1980, le transporteur est solidairement tenu à payer, avec l'étranger qu'il a transporté et qui par la suite d'une décision des autorités d'immigration doit être refoulé parce qu'il ne disposait pas des documents de voyage requis à l'article 2 de la loi, les frais de séjour redevables à l'Etat suite au séjour de ce dernier dans un centre fermé situé à la frontière. Le montant journalier des frais de séjour est fixé par arrêté royal.En 2003, le coût par jour s'élevait à 37,5 euros par jour par rapport à 38,10 euros par jour en 2004. Source: Rapport d'activités de l'Office des Etrangers pour l'année 2004: http://www.dofi.fgov.be/fr/activiteitenrapport/RapportActivité_2004.pdf, page 57
Presently there are 628 places in Belgian detention centres and an estimate that around 8.000 people are detained each year. (http://www.cire.irisnet.be/ouvrons/fr/centres-fermes.html#belgique). Thus, in 2004, if each person were detained for only one day, this costs at least 8.000 x 38,10 = 304.800,00 UR.
In Belgium, a person can be detained for, initially, 2 months, and then this time can be extended to 4, 5 and 8 months and even longer because it is considered that every time a person opposes his/her removal, it is a complete new period of detention that begins (http://www.cire.irisnet.be/ouvrons/fr/centres-fermes.html#belgique). Thus, if one person is detained for, f. ex. 5 months (3 x 30 days + 2 x 31 days = 152 days) this costs at least 152 x 38,10 UR = 5.791,20 UR.
If 8.000 people were detained for 5 months, this costs at least 5.791,20 UR x 8.000 = 46.329.600,00 UR per year (2004) or, in other words, this is the amount of which the Belgian government thinks that it is justified.
BULGARIA
According to the information provided by the Department of International Cooperation of the Ministry of the Interior, the cost of maintaining a detained illegal migrant per day in Bulgaria amounts to 4.30 BGN (equivalent to approximately US $3), including 1.30 BGN for daily nutrition costs. No information is available on the relative costs of detention in comparison with other alternatives, but in cases where indefinite detention may occur, the authorities often find it both more humane and more affordable to release the failed asylum seeker on condition of frequent reporting requirements. SOURCE: UNHCR LEGAL AND PROTECTION POLICY, RESEARCH SERIES, Alternatives to Detention of Asylum Seekers and Refugees, Ophelia Field with the assistance of Alice Edwards, External Consultants, DIVISION OF INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION SERVICES, POLAS/2006/03, April 2006, Extract, page 82
DENMARK
There is only one detention centre in Denmark, in Sandholm. The total budget provided to detention of asylum seekers for 2006 was close to 34 million Danish Kr. (4.560.881,00 EUR as of 6 November 2006).
SOURCE 6 November 2006: Permanent Representation of Denmark to the European Union, Brussels
GERMANY BAVARIA, Year 2005
The total cost of pre-removal detention was 6.6 Mio EUR. Taking into account that 1.177 persons were removed and 237 persons were released, this means an average of 4.667,61 EUR per person or an average of 5.607,48 EUR per person removed. - The total cost for removal (without counting cost for persons accompanying the forcible return, such as boarder guards) was nearly 1.5 Mio EUR. Thus detention and removal together cost 8.1 Mio EUR, which amounts to an average of 6.881,90 EUR per person removed. - If an estimated 1.800,00 EUR were added for 2 persons accompanying the forcible return, such as boarder guards, the entire operation would cost approximately 8.700,00 EUR per person. SOURCE: CONFIDENTIAL
GERMANY - BERLIN, July 2006
Year (Jahr)
|
2001
|
2002-2004
|
2005
|
daily rate (Tagessatz)
|
60,51
|
61,92
|
65,99
|
incl. guards (Wachpersonal)
|
37,58
|
38,79
|
37,43
|
incl. medical care (Medizinische Betreuung)
|
5,01
|
4,86
|
10,56
|
incl. general cost (Sachkosten)
|
11,70
|
11,70
|
11,70
|
incl. food (Verpflegung)
|
6,14
|
6,47
|
6,05
|
incl. TV (Fernseher/GEZ)
|
0,08
|
0,10
|
0,25
|
SOURCE: Abgeordnetenhaus Berlin, Drucksache 15/13 505, 14. July 2006 (http://www.parlament-berlin.de:8080/starweb/adis/citat/VT/15/KlAnfr/ka15-13505.pdf)
IRELAND DOCHAS, June 2006
In 2005, 105 women were detained. The cost of maintaining a person per year is is approximately 219,00 UR per day. This includes food, phone calls, health care, staffing, transport to Court, hospital etc. SOURCE: CONFIDENTIAL
THE NETHERLANDS
A place in an open reception centre costs 13.000,00 UR on average per person per year. The government intends to reduce this to 11.000,00 UR. Equivalent figures for the cost of de facto detention at the application centres (ACs) are unavailable, but the deterrence effect of the accelerated procedure may be considered by some policy makers to be worth the cost. SOURCE: UNHCR LEGAL AND PROTECTION POLICY, RESEARCH SERIES, Alternatives to Detention of Asylum Seekers and Refugees, Ophelia Field with the assistance of Alice Edwards, External Consultants, DIVISION OF INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION SERVICES, POLAS/2006/03, April 2006, Extract, page 159
POLAND 2006
The average budget for administering one pre-removal arrest with capacity for 56 persons is 414.100 PLN (1 Polish Zloty = roughly 0,25 UR). The salaries of civil servants and technical staff are not included. 1 UR = 4 Zloty 4 Zloty = 1 UR 414.100 Zloty = 103.525,00 UR per year 103.535,00 UR per year divided by 12 months = 8.627,00 UR per month 103.535,00 UR per year divided by 365 days = 283,00 UR per day 1 Vietnamese (for example) detained for 8 month: 8.627,00 UR multiplied by 8 = 69.016,00 UR 1 person average detained for 6 months: 8.627,00 UR multiplied by 6 = 51.762,00 UR 182 days = 6 months 51.762,00 UR divided by 182 = 284,00 UR per day SOURCE: CONFIDENTIAL
SLOVENIA, June 2006
For detaining a person in Centre for foreigners: is 3.800 SIT per day (= approximately 15,83 UR), an amount for only basic things; when medical care is provided, cost are higher. SOURCE: CONFIDENTIAL
UNITED KINGDOM
The Home Office generally does not publish figures on the financial costs of immigration detention. In answer to a 2007 request made under the Freedom of Information Act, the Home Office revealed that in 2005/6 the weekly cost per detainee ranged from £511 (Lindholme IRC) to £1,344 (Colnbrook IRC). The cost of detaining someone in the DFT system in the now-closed Oakington IRC cost £1,620 per week (ICAR 2007).
On 4 February 2010, the UK Government reported in Parliament that the average overall cost of one bed per day in the immigration detention estate is £120 (included in these estimates are the costs incurred by incidents such as fires in IRCs or individuals suing for unlawful detention) (Hansard 2010). This enables us to estimate the annual costs of particular IRCs. For example, since we know that Campsfield House IRC usually operates at 90% capacity with 194 (of a possible 216) migrants detained there, we can estimate that this particular IRC costs approximately £8,497,200 per year to run.
(Source of UK statistics, last visited on 29/04/2011: http://www.migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/briefings/immigration-detention-uk)
|